When Knowledge Falls Flat

A monk, an elbow on an airport bus, and what it means in an age of AI

Joe Powers - 11/21/26

In 2004 I was invited to a meeting with the Venerable Tenzin Yignyen, who was then teaching Tibetan Buddhism at Hobart and William Smith Colleges in Geneva, New York, and we struck up a brief friendship. Tenzin had fled Tibet with his parents as a young boy. At sixteen he entered Namgyal Monastery in India, where he was ordained by the Dalai Lama and trained for sixteen years.

Compassion was at the center of that training. He told me that as part of his training, for years he would sit in meditation and think of every negative thing someone could say to him and contemplate it, until nothing anyone said could disrupt his compassion, at least in his mind.

Illustration of a Tibetan monk on a crowded airport bus, jostled by the man beside him.

AI-generated art inspired by Tenzin’s story.

Then he made his first trip to the United States. At JFK Airport in New York, on the bus from the plane to the terminal, a man elbowed him, and in that moment he got upset. He told me that he felt as though he lost his years of training in that very moment, as if they had meant nothing.

What he said next has stayed with me. Being in a monastery, or in one's own mind, is easy. Practicing kindness and compassion is much harder in the real world, where we meet challenges and other people.

I have carried this story for twenty years and share it often. As an academic, knowledge was everything to me, and Tenzin's story turned that back on me. It showed me there was so much more, and it instilled in me a guiding principle: it's not just what we know, but how we put it into action for the betterment of others.

Knowledge can be overrated in how we relate to each other. We can learn everything about a subject and still miss the emotions and miss what it means to be in the experience or the shoes of another. That is empathy, and it is what I mean by bearing witness in the design methodology I teach and practice.

I think about Tenzin's story more now because of AI. AI is unquestionably advanced in knowledge, and it is easy to idealize it for that. I fear we are doing what Tenzin did in the monastery, and to an extent what I did in academia, expanding the mind at the expense of the heart.

I see this as a trap. We often think knowledge is the ultimate aim, as if the more we know, the better off we will be, and I've experienced in many organizations a tendency to rank knowing over caring. The AI hype reinforces this and tells us knowledge will be our salvation, but knowledge can only go so far.

On its own, it falls flat in the face of compassion and kindness. I want us to be clear about this, and to reevaluate what it means to be all knowing. For me, the knowing that matters most often comes from simply being with another person and making a heartfelt connection.

Next
Next

Narrowing the Gap Between self and Self